Crowdsourcing Job Satisfaction Data: Examining the Construct Validity of Glassdoor.com Ratings

Authors

Richard N. Landers, University of MinnesotaFollow
Robert C. Brusso, Capital OneFollow
Elena M. Auer, University of MinnesotaFollow

DOI

https://doi.org/10.25035/pad.2019.03.006

Abstract

Researchers, practitioners, and job seekers now routinely use crowdsourced data about organizations for both decision-making and research purposes. Despite the popularity of such websites, empirical evidence regarding their validity is generally absent. In this study, we tackled this problem by combining two curated datasets: (a) the results of the 2017 Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey (FEVS), which contains facet-level job satisfaction ratings from 407,789 US federal employees, and which we aggregated to the agency level, and (b) current overall and facet ratings of job satisfaction of the federal agencies contained within FEVS from Glassdoor.com as scraped from the Glassdoor application programming interface (API) within a month of the FEVS survey’s administration. Using these data, we examined convergent validity, discriminant validity, and methods effects for the measurement of both overall and facet-level job satisfaction by analyzing a multitrait-multimethod matrix (MTMM). Most centrally, we provide evidence that overall Glassdoor ratings of satisfaction within US federal agencies correlate moderately with aggregated FEVS overall ratings (r = .516), supporting the validity of the overall Glassdoor rating as a measure of overall job satisfaction aggregated to the organizational level. In contrast, the validity of facet-level measurement was not well-supported. Overall, given varying strengths and weaknesses with both Glassdoor and survey data, we recommend the combined use of both traditional and crowdsourced data on organizational characteristics for both research and practice.

Recommended Citation

Landers, Richard N.; Brusso, Robert C.; and Auer, Elena M. (2019) "Crowdsourcing Job Satisfaction Data: Examining the Construct Validity of Glassdoor.com Ratings," Personnel Assessment and Decisions: Number 5 : Iss. 3 , Article 6.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.25035/pad.2019.03.006
Available at: https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/pad/vol5/iss3/6

Corresponding Author Information

Richard N. Landers

rlanders@umn.edu

Department of Psychology 75 E River Road Minneapolis, MN 55455